Sofia Franklyn and Peter Nelson were previously in a romantic relationship that attracted public attention during the 2020 Call Her Daddy podcast controversy. Franklyn confirmed their breakup in 2023, and in June 2025 she disputed claims that Nelson had orchestrated her business negotiations with Barstool Sports. Sofia has since moved on: she married finance professional Josh Messamore in Italy in 2026. Peter Nelson is her former boyfriend, not her husband.
Sofia Franklyn and Peter Nelson became a widely discussed couple during the controversy surrounding the popular podcast Call Her Daddy. Their relationship attracted attention because Nelson, a former HBO Sports executive, became connected to the public dispute between Franklyn, her former co-host Alex Cooper and Barstool Sports in 2020.
However, their relationship eventually ended. Franklyn publicly confirmed the breakup in 2023, bringing an end to one of the most discussed personal relationships connected to the podcast’s early years.
The story has received renewed attention in 2025 and 2026 as Franklyn has spoken more openly about her past, addressed claims surrounding Nelson’s involvement in her career decisions and moved into a new chapter of her personal life.
In 2026, Franklyn married finance professional Josh Messamore in Italy. This is an important distinction for readers searching for Sofia Franklyn and Peter: Nelson is her former boyfriend, while Messamore is her husband.
Understanding their relationship requires looking at three connected developments: Franklyn’s rise to podcast fame, the controversy that brought Nelson into the public conversation, and the events that followed their separation.
What Happened Between Sofia Franklyn and Peter Nelson?
Sofia Franklyn and Peter Nelson were romantically involved during the period when Franklyn co-hosted Call Her Daddy with Alex Cooper.
Nelson was an HBO Sports executive who became publicly associated with the podcast’s contract negotiations in 2020.
At the time, Franklyn and Cooper were negotiating with Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy about the future of their successful podcast.
The negotiations became controversial after disagreements emerged over the proposed contract and the direction of the show.
Nelson was subsequently discussed in media reports and online conversations because of his relationship with Franklyn. Some accounts suggested he had influenced her professional decisions.
However, Franklyn later challenged that portrayal.
In a June 16, 2025 interview on Jason Tartick’s Trading Secrets podcast, she said the media had overstated Nelson’s involvement in the negotiations. She explained that he was her boyfriend and that naturally she discussed her work and personal life with him.
This clarification is important because it distinguishes Franklyn’s own account from the speculation that surrounded the couple during the podcast controversy. Us+1
Who Is Peter Nelson? A Look at His Career and Background
Peter Nelson is a former HBO Sports executive who became known outside the television industry because of his relationship with Sofia Franklyn.
He held a senior position at HBO and was involved in the sports media business during the period when Franklyn and Cooper were building Call Her Daddy into a successful podcast.
Nelson became a subject of public discussion in 2020 when reports connected him to the podcast’s contract negotiations.
Peter Nelson’s professional background
Nelson’s professional identity is primarily associated with sports television and media management.
He worked at HBO, where he held an executive role in the sports division.
His position placed him within the television industry at a time when traditional broadcasters were competing with digital platforms and independent media companies for audiences.
Although his relationship with Franklyn made him a subject of celebrity coverage, he has generally maintained a much lower public profile than the podcast personality.
There is limited independently verified information about his current professional activities, personal life and relationship status. Therefore, claims about his current employment or romantic relationships should be treated cautiously.
How Did Peter Nelson Become Connected to the Call Her Daddy Controversy?
To understand why Sofia Franklyn and Peter Nelson became such a widely searched topic, it is necessary to revisit the Call Her Daddy controversy.
The beginning of Call Her Daddy
Sofia Franklyn and Alex Cooper launched Call Her Daddy in 2018.
The show quickly developed a large audience because of its frank conversations about dating, relationships, sex and modern social life.
The podcast became associated with Barstool Sports, which helped it expand its reach.
Franklyn and Cooper became popular personalities, and their partnership appeared to be a successful business arrangement.
However, the situation changed in 2020 when the hosts began negotiating a new agreement with Barstool Sports.
The 2020 contract dispute
The disagreement centred on the podcast’s future, ownership and financial arrangements.
Dave Portnoy, the founder of Barstool Sports, became publicly involved in the negotiations.
The situation escalated after reports suggested that the two hosts were considering alternative arrangements with other media companies.
Peter Nelson’s name entered the conversation because he was Franklyn’s boyfriend and worked in the media industry.
Some public accounts suggested that he had encouraged Franklyn to seek a different deal.
However, these claims were disputed, and the precise extent of his involvement became a subject of disagreement.
The negotiations ultimately resulted in Alex Cooper continuing Call Her Daddy without Franklyn.
Franklyn left the original show and later launched her own podcast, Sofia with an F, in October 2020.
The disagreement also affected the friendship and professional relationship between the two former co-hosts.
What was Peter Nelson’s nickname?
Peter Nelson became known online as “Suitman” during the Call Her Daddy controversy.
The nickname was used in discussions surrounding his business background and alleged involvement in the podcast negotiations.
It became part of the wider online conversation about Franklyn, Cooper and Barstool Sports.
However, the nickname should not be confused with an official professional title or position.
What Did Sofia Franklyn Say About Peter Nelson in 2025?
One of the most important updates about Sofia Franklyn and Peter came in June 2025.
Franklyn appeared on Jason Tartick’s Trading Secrets podcast, where she discussed her former relationship and the public narrative surrounding Nelson.
In the interview, she challenged the idea that Nelson had played a major role in the Barstool negotiations.
She explained that he was her boyfriend at the time and that discussing work with a romantic partner was normal.
She also said that the media had portrayed his involvement as greater than it actually was.
This was significant because the public had spent years discussing Nelson’s alleged influence on Franklyn’s career decisions.
Why did Sofia Franklyn want to keep future relationships private?
During the same interview, Franklyn discussed how the negative attention surrounding her relationship with Nelson affected her approach to dating.
She explained that she did not want a future partner to experience unwanted public scrutiny.
Her concern was not simply that a relationship might attract attention. Rather, she did not want someone who had not chosen a public career to become part of a celebrity news story.
This helps explain why she kept details about her next relationship relatively private.
The June 16, 2025 Us Weekly report provides an account of the interview and her comments. Us
When Did Sofia Franklyn and Peter Nelson Break Up?
Sofia Franklyn confirmed that she and Peter Nelson had ended their relationship in a 2023 episode of Bradley Martyn’s Raw Talk podcast.
The breakup did not receive the same level of public attention as their relationship during the 2020 podcast dispute.
Franklyn later discussed the relationship in interviews, including her June 2025 appearance on Trading Secrets.
In the 2025 interview, she reflected on how the experience had influenced her decision to keep future romantic relationships away from public scrutiny.
The exact date of their separation has not been established through a widely documented public announcement.
It is therefore more accurate to say that their breakup was publicly confirmed in 2023 rather than assign an unverified separation date.
Did Peter Nelson and Sofia Franklyn get married?
No. There is no verified public evidence that Sofia Franklyn and Peter Nelson ever married or became engaged.
They were in a romantic relationship, but their relationship ended before Franklyn’s subsequent engagement and marriage.
Searches about Sofia Franklyn’s husband should therefore distinguish between Peter Nelson, her former boyfriend, and her current husband, John Messamore.
Who Is Sofia Franklyn’s Husband Now?
Sofia Franklyn is now married to John Messamore, a finance professional whom she met through a matchmaking service.
Their relationship marked a new chapter after her separation from Peter Nelson.
Unlike her previous relationship, Franklyn initially kept her new partner’s identity private. She gradually shared details about their romance through her podcast and interviews.
How did Sofia Franklyn meet John Messamore?
In an April 14, 2026 interview with Elite Daily, Franklyn explained that she met her future husband through a professional matchmaking service in the summer of 2024.
A close friend who worked as a matchmaker encouraged her to try the service.
The agency asked detailed questions about her expectations, including marriage, family plans and the type of relationship she wanted.
Franklyn said the approach helped her meet people who were interested in similar long-term goals.
Their first date took place at Fouquet’s, a French restaurant in Manhattan.
She explained that she recognised something different about the relationship early on.
One memorable detail involved a childhood book, The Missing Piece Meets the Big O by Shel Silverstein. Franklyn discussed the book during their first date, and her future husband later bought her a copy.
The thoughtful gesture became an important memory in their relationship.
When did Sofia Franklyn get engaged?
Franklyn announced her engagement in September 2025.
She had previously kept her fiancé’s identity largely private, although she occasionally shared glimpses of their relationship.
During her April 2026 interview, she described the proposal, which happened during a road trip through Europe.
Her fiancé proposed in Provence, France.
She explained that she was initially surprised by the ring and needed a moment to realise that the proposal was serious.
The couple subsequently began planning their wedding.Elite Daily
When did Sofia Franklyn marry John Messamore?
Sofia Franklyn and John Messamore married on August 2, 2026, at Villa Pizzo in Cernobbio, Italy.
Their wedding was part of a three-day celebration around Lake Como.
According to PEOPLE, the festivities began with a welcome dinner on July 31 in Argegno.
The following day included activities such as pasta making, wine tasting and watercolor painting.
The main wedding ceremony and reception took place on August 2 at Villa Pizzo.
Franklyn announced the marriage on Instagram on August 28, 2026, using the wedding date as her caption: “8.2.26.”
The celebration marked a significant personal milestone for the podcast host, who had previously spoken about her complicated experiences with dating and relationships. People.com+1
Sofia Franklyn’s Latest Relationship Update in November 2026
Sofia Franklyn’s personal life has continued to attract attention following her marriage.
One of the latest updates came on November 9, 2026, when she appeared on The Bossticks podcast with Lauryn and Michael Bosstick.
During the conversation, Franklyn discussed her personal experiences, her forthcoming memoir Daddy Issues and her plans for starting a family with her husband.
According to PEOPLE, Franklyn said that she and John Messamore hope to have children soon.
She also discussed how writing about a previous abortion in her memoir brought up complicated emotions as she considered becoming a mother.
The conversation offered a more personal look at her life after the end of her relationship with Peter Nelson.
Sofia Franklyn’s memoir Daddy Issues
Franklyn’s forthcoming memoir, Daddy Issues, is another important development in her life in 2026.
The book explores different aspects of her upbringing, relationships, professional journey and experiences in the entertainment industry.
Its publication has renewed interest in her earlier years, including the Call Her Daddy controversy and the relationship with Peter Nelson.
Franklyn has also discussed how the experience of losing her original podcast partnership affected her professional identity and personal relationships.
Her recent interviews suggest that she is now more comfortable discussing her experiences while maintaining boundaries around the privacy of her husband.People.com+2
What Did the People Involved Say?
There has not been a joint public statement from Peter Nelson and Sofia Franklyn about their breakup.
However, Franklyn has provided important information through her own interviews.
The main publicly documented comments include:
- Sofia Franklyn, June 2025: She disputed the suggestion that Peter Nelson had been heavily involved in the podcast negotiations.
- Sofia Franklyn, June 2025: She explained that the negative media attention surrounding her former relationship influenced her decision to protect future partners’ privacy.
- Sofia Franklyn, April 2026: She discussed meeting her future husband through matchmaking and explained why their relationship felt different.
- Sofia Franklyn, November 2026: She discussed her marriage to John Messamore and their hopes of having children.
It is important to separate Franklyn’s own comments from claims made by other people during the 2020 podcast dispute.
Peter Nelson has not provided a verified public response to all the claims and speculation surrounding their former relationship.
Why the Sofia Franklyn and Peter Nelson Story Still Matters
The continued interest in Sofia Franklyn and Peter Nelson is closely connected to the history of Call Her Daddy.
Their relationship became part of a much larger entertainment story involving friendship, business negotiations, podcast ownership and the influence of personal relationships on professional decisions.
There are three important reasons the story continues to attract attention.
1. The Call Her Daddy controversy remains widely discussed
The podcast became one of the most recognisable examples of a successful digital media partnership ending publicly.
Franklyn’s departure and Cooper’s decision to continue the show created lasting interest in what happened behind the scenes.
2. Peter Nelson’s role was widely debated
Because Nelson worked in the media industry and was dating Franklyn, his name became closely associated with the negotiations.
Franklyn’s 2025 clarification added important context to the discussion.
3. Sofia Franklyn has entered a new personal chapter
Her engagement and 2026 marriage have shifted public interest towards her current relationship.
Readers searching for her former boyfriend may also want to know who she married and what she is doing now.
The key distinction is that Peter Nelson belongs to her past relationship history, while John Messamore is her current husband.
What Happens Next for Sofia Franklyn and Peter Nelson?
There is no confirmed indication that Sofia Franklyn and Peter Nelson plan to reconnect or publicly discuss their former relationship together.
Franklyn is now married to John Messamore and has discussed their hopes of starting a family.
Her professional focus also includes her podcast, Sofia with an F, and her memoir, Daddy Issues.
As for Nelson, there is limited verified public information about his current personal life and professional activities.
Unless either person makes a new public statement, further claims about their relationship should be treated as speculation.
For readers, the most important update is that the relationship between Sofia Franklyn and Peter Nelson ended, and Franklyn has since married someone else.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Who is Sofia Franklyn’s ex-boyfriend Peter?
Peter Nelson is a former HBO Sports executive who previously dated podcast host Sofia Franklyn. He became widely known during the 2020 Call Her Daddy controversy because of his reported connection to the podcast’s contract negotiations.
2. Are Sofia Franklyn and Peter Nelson still together?
No. Sofia Franklyn confirmed in 2023 that she and Peter Nelson had ended their relationship. She has since moved on and married John Messamore in 2026.
3. Why did Sofia Franklyn and Peter Nelson break up?
The exact reasons for their separation have not been fully disclosed publicly. Franklyn confirmed their breakup in 2023 but has not provided a comprehensive public explanation of every factor behind it.
4. What does Peter Nelson do?
Peter Nelson is known for his former executive role at HBO Sports. He became a subject of entertainment news coverage because of his relationship with Sofia Franklyn and the Call Her Daddy controversy.
5. Did Peter Nelson influence the Call Her Daddy negotiations?
His involvement was widely discussed during the 2020 controversy. However, in a June 2025 interview with Jason Tartick, Franklyn disputed claims that Nelson had played a major role, explaining that media coverage had overstated his involvement.
6. Who is Sofia Franklyn married to in 2026?
Sofia Franklyn is married to John Messamore, a finance professional. They married on August 2, 2026, at Villa Pizzo in Cernobbio, Italy, following a three-day celebration around Lake Como.
7. When did Sofia Franklyn meet her new husband?
Franklyn met John Messamore through a professional matchmaking service in the summer of 2024. Their first date took place at Fouquet’s restaurant in Manhattan.
8. Does Sofia Franklyn have children?
As of November 2026, there is no publicly confirmed announcement that Sofia Franklyn has children. She recently said that she and her husband hope to have children soon.
9. Why is Sofia Franklyn famous?
Sofia Franklyn is an American podcast host and media personality. She became famous as the co-creator and original co-host of Call Her Daddy with Alex Cooper. After leaving the show in 2020, she launched her own podcast, Sofia with an F.
10. What is Sofia Franklyn’s latest news?
In November 2026, Franklyn discussed her marriage, plans to have children and personal experiences on The Bossticks podcast. She is also promoting her memoir, Daddy Issues.
